Skip to main content
Old Cutler Inn logo top - HomepageOld Cutler Inn logo scroll - Homepage
  • (866)-519-1804
  • info@oldcutlerinn.com
  • ReservationS
  • Menus
    • Food
    • Drinks
  • About
  • Private Events
  • Order ONLINE
  • *
  • Press
  • Gift Cards
  • Blogs
  • Order ONLINE
  • Facebook page
  • Instagram page
Old Cutler Inn logo top - HomepageOld Cutler Inn logo scroll - Homepage
  • Book a Party, opens in a new tab
  • ReservationS
  • Menus
    • Food
    • Drinks
  • About
  • Private Events
  • Order ONLINE
  • *
  • Press
  • Gift Cards
  • Blogs
  • Order ONLINE

Our Menu

  • Lunch Menu
  • Dinner Menu
  • Kids Menu
  • Dessert Menu
  • Happy Hour
  • Breakfast
  • Sunday Brunch

G gluten l D dairy l E egg l S soy l SE sesame l F fish l SH shellfish l PN peanut l TN tree nuts l M mustard V vegetarian l VG vegan l GF prepared without gluten

Appetizers

Yellowfin Tuna Tartar

$23.00
Eggplant, avocado-yuzu, mojo rojo, toston • F, S, GF

Local Fish Dip

$16.00
Pickled fresno, saltine crackers, lemon, OCI hot sauce • F, D, G

Chicken Wings

$14.00/6 pc
$24.00/12 pc
Guava BBQ sauce, blue cheese dressing, celery & carrots • G, D, E, S

Wagyu Meatballs

$21.00
Sunday sauce, ricotta, pesto, sourdough • G, D, E, TN

Soup & Salads

Roasted Tomato Soup

$13.00
Oven dried cherry tomato, basil • Add Classic Grilled Cheese +$5.00 • G, VG

Roasted Chicken Caesar

$22.00
Kale, romaine hearts, boquerones, creamy Caesar dressing, garlic croutons, parmesan • F, G, D, E, M

Blackened Shrimp Cobb

$26.00
Key west shrimp, tomato, bacon, egg, avocado, scallion, blue cheese, apple-cider dressing • SH, D, E

Grilled Peach Panzanella

$24.00
Prosciutto, tomato, whipped cottage cheese, sourdough croutons, basil, sherry vinaigrette • G, D

Sesame Crusted Tuna

$28.00
Chopped kimchi, mixed greens, edamame, avocado, cucumber, carrot, peanuts, sesame vinaigrette • F, S, SE, PN, GF

Avocado Toast

$12.00
Smashed avocado, pickled onion, chili flakes, multigrain • Add: Tomato +$3.00, Poached Egg +$4.00, Smoked Salmon +$10.00 • G, E, F

Bowls

Mediterranean

$25.00
Grilled chicken breast, quinoa, cucumber, tomato, kalamata olives, pickled red onion, feta, tahini, lemon vinaigrette • D, SE, GF

Asian Salmon

$28.00
Miso-glazed salmon, jasmine rice, sesame cucumber, edamame, avocado, ginger-soy vinegar ginger-scallion sauce • F, S, SE, GF

Poke

$27.00
Jasmine rice, sesame cucumber, edamame, avocado, ponzu • Choice of: Spicy Tuna or Salmon • F, S, SE

Handhelds

Oci Smashie

$22.00
Cheddar, shaved onion, b+b pickle, special sauce, sesame challah bun • Add: Thick Cut Bacon +$3.00, Fried Egg +$2.00 • G, D, E, SE

Turkey BLT

$18.00
Miso bacon, shaved lettuce, tomato, roasted garlic mayo, white bread • G, E, S

Fried Chicken

$19.00
Cole slaw, b&b pickles, spicy mayo, challah bun • G, D, E, M

Local Catch

MKT
Little gem lettuce, dill tartar sauce, b&b pickles, challah bun • F, G, D, E

Sourdough Flatbreads

Plain Jane

$14.00
Marinara, mozzarella cheese • G, D, V

Pep & Honey

$16.00
Pepperoni cups, marinara, mozzarella, oregano, hot honey • G, D

Shorty

$19.00
Beef ragu, vodka cream sauce, oven dried tomato, mozzarella, basil pesto • G, D, TN

Fun Guy

$18.00
Mushroom, prosciutto, fig jam, baby arugula, goat cheese, balsamic reduction • G, D

Entrées

Spicy Rigatoni

$28.00
Oven dried cherry tomato, torn basil, vodka cream sauce, chili-garlic breadcrumbs • G, D

Pan Roasted Mahi

$42.00
Cucumber relish, ember roasted sweet potato, grilled asparagus, dill remoulade • F, D, E

½ Chicken

$35.00
Mojo crispy yuca, grilled little gem salad & fermented ahi verde sauce • G, D, E, M

Pork Schnitzel

$34.00
Warm fingerling potato salad, cornichon relish, grainy mustard jus • G, D, E, M

Baby Back Ribs

$38.00
Tamarind BBQ, jalapeno cornbread, cole slaw, seasoned shoestring fries • G, D, E

Steak & Frites

$68.00
14oz delmonico ribeye steak, shoestring fries, mushroom ragu • D, GF

Sides

Parker Rolls

$8.00
Shallot butter • G, D, E

Mac & Cheese

$14.00
Bacon, cheese sauce & ritz crust • G, D

House Salad

$7.00
Little gem, red onion, tomato, apple cider vinaigrette • VG, GF

Potato Wedges

$8.00
Special sauce • E, G

G gluten l D dairy l E egg l S soy l SE sesame l F fish l SH shellfish l PN peanut l TN tree nuts l M mustard V vegetarian l VG vegan l GF prepared without gluten

Raw Bar

East Coast Oyster

1/2 Dozen $24.00 | Dozen $46.00 • Mignonette, cocktail sauce, lemon • SH, GF, Pesc

Beef Carpaccio

$28.00
Truffle aioli, egg, caper, rye crumble, parmesan, arugula • G, D, E, M, Beef

Yellowfin Tuna Tartare

$23.00
Eggplant caponata, avocado-yuzu, mojo rojo, tostones • F, S, GF

Appetizers

Local Fish Dip

$16.00
Pickled fresno, saltine crackers, lemon, OCI hot sauce • F, D, G

Cornmeal Crusted Calamari

$18.00
Fried herb, Calabrian chili aioli, grilled lemon • SH, G, E, M, Pesc

Wagyu Meatballs

$21.00
Sunday sauce, ricotta, basil pesto, grilled sourdough • G, D, E, TN

Chicken Wings

$14.00/6 pc
$24.00/12 pc
Guava BBQ sauce, blue cheese dressing, celery & carrots • G, D, E, S

Sourdough Flatbreads

Plain Jane

$14.00
Marinara, mozzerella cheese • G, D, V

Pep & Honey

$16.00
Pepperoni cups, marinara, mozzarella, oregano, hot honey • G, D

Shorty

$19.00
Beef ragu, vodka cream sauce, oven dried tomato, mozzarella, basil pesto • G, D, TN

Fun Guy

$18.00
Mushroom, prosciutto, fig jam, baby arugula, goat cheese, balsamic reduction • G, D

Soup & Salads

Tomato Soup

$13.00
Oven dried cherry tomato, basil • G, VG

Roasted Chicken Caesar

$22.00
Kale, little gem, boquerone anchovies, creamy Caesar dressing, croutons, parmesan • F, G, D, E, M

Blackened Shrimp Cobb

$28.00
Key west shrimp, tomato, bacon, egg, avocado, scallion, blue cheese, apple-cider dressing • SH, D, E

OCI Wedge

$24.00
Iceberg lettuce, miso bacon, cherry tomato, blue cheese • F, G, E, M, GF

Grilled Peach Panzanella

$24.00
Prosciutto, tomato, whipped cottage cheese, sourdough croutons, basil, sherry vinaigrette • G, D

Sesame Crusted Tuna

$28.00
Chopped kimchi, mixed greens, edamame, avocado, cucumber, carrot, peanuts, sesame vinaigrette • F, S, SE, PN, GF

Entrées

OCI Smashie

$22.00
Cheddar, shaved onion, b+b pickle, special sauce, sesame challah bun • Add: Bacon +$3.00, Fried Egg +$3.00 • G, D, E, SE

Spicy Rigatoni

$28.00
Oven dried cherry tomato, basil, vodka cream sauce, chili-garlic breadcrumb • G, D

Pan Roasted Mahi

$42.00
Sweet potato, grilled asparagus, cucumber relish, dill remoulade • F, D, E

1/2 Chicken

$35.00
Mojo crispy yuca, grilled little gem salad & fermented ahi verde sauce • G, D, E, M

Pork Schnitzel

$34.00
Warm fingerling potato salad, cornichon relish, grainy mustard jus • G, D, E, M

Baby Back Ribs

$38.00
Tamarind BBQ, jalapeno cornbread, cole slaw, cajun shoestring fries • G, D, E

Meatloaf

$35.00
Potato puree, buttered shiitake mushroom, sweet peas, tomato jam • G, D, E, M, F, Beef

Steak & Frites

$65.00
14oz delmonico ribeye steak, shoestring fries, bordelaise mushroom-ragu • D, GF

Sides

Parker Rolls

$8.00
Shallot butter • G, D, E

Mac & Cheese

$14.00
Bacon, cheddar cheese sauce & ritz cracker crust • G, D

Little House Salad

$7.00
Little gem, red onion, tomato, apple cider vinaigrette • VG, GF

Potato Wedges

$8.00
Special sauce • E, G

Loaded Potato

$12.00
Idaho potato, sour cream, shredder cheddar, miso bacon bits, chives • D, S, Pork, GF

Food

Cheese Flatbread

Marinara, mozzarella

Butter Noodles

Spaghetti, parmesan cheese

Chicken Fingers

Potato wedges & honey mustard

Smash Cheese Burger

Potato wedges

Dessert

A La Carte
1 Scoop | 2 Scoops | 3 Scoops

Vanilla Ice Cream Sundae

Hot fudge, whipped cream, cherry

Vanilla Bean Ice Cream

Chocolate Ice Cream

Strawberry Ice Cream

Dessert

Oci Key Lime Pie

Graham cracker & macadamia crust, key lime custard, topped with Italian meringue

Chocolate Cake

Ganache, chocolate sponge, wood-roasted blackberry sauce

Guava Blondie Skillet

White chocolate, guava, vanilla ice cream

Classic Bread Pudding

Golden raisins, toasted pecans, salted caramel sauce, vanilla ice cream

Ice Creams & Sorbet

A La Carte
1 Scoop | 2 Scoops | 3 Scoops

Seasonal Sundae

Chef’s weekly selection

Ice Creams

• Vanilla Bean Ice Cream
• Chocolate Ice Cream
• Strawberry Ice Cream

Local Seasonal Sorbet

• Mango
• Guava

Sorbet & Ice Cream Sampler

Choice of any three scoops, served on a bed of fresh berries

Same great energy, just a little happier.

Cocktails

House Margarita

$12.00
Tequila, lime, agave

Mojito

$12.00
Rum, fresh mint, lime, soda

Old Fashioned

$12.00
Bourbon, house bitters, orange

Lemon Drop Martini

$12.00
Vodka, lemon, simple, sugar rim

Espresso Martini

$12.00
Vodka, espresso liqueur, espresso

French 75

$12.00
Gin, lemon, simple, champagne

Draft | Can | Bottled Beer

$6.00

House Red | White | Sparkling Wine

$10.00

Tuna Tostones

$10.00

Pep & Honey Flatbread

$10.00

Chicken Wings

$10.00

Loaded Potato Wedges

$10.00

Half Dozen Oysters

$10.00

Beer Specials

Draft Beer

$6.00

Bottled Beer

$6.00

Canned Beer

$6.00

Wine Specials

House Red

$10.00

House White

$10.00

Sparkling

$10.00

Bar Bites

Tuna Tostones

$10.00

Pep & Honey Flat Bread

$10.00

Wings

$10.00

Loaded Potato Wedges

$10.00

Half Dozen Oysters

$10.00

Hours for Breakfast are Wednesday - Sunday, 9 am - 11 am

Breakfast Menu

Avocado Toast

Smashed avocado, pickled onion, chili flakes, multigrain | Add Tomato, Soft Poached Egg, and Smoked Salmon for an additional price

Oci Breakfast

Three eggs your way, Bacon or Sausage, home fries & choice of toast | Add Two Pancakes for an additional price

Egg & Cheddar Sandwich

Egg your way, cheddar, Bacon or Sausage, spicy mayo, challah bun

Classic Breakfast Burrito

Scrambled eggs, home fries, chorizo, cheddar, avocado, salsa verde

Bagel & Lox

Choice of: Plain or Anything Bagel, smoked salmon, cream cheese, red onion, capers, lemon, dill

Buttermilk Pancakes

Whipped butter, warm maple syrup | Add chocolate chips for an additional price

Protein Bowl

Eggs you way, breakfast potato, avocado, cherry tomato, baby spinach, scallion, everything-spice, tahini dressing | Add Marinated Steak for an additional price

House Yogurt

Greek yogurt, seasonal fruit, house granola, local honey

Morning Beverage

Oat, Almond, or Whole Milk Available

Tropical Sunrise Smoothie

Mango, banana, coconut water

Berry & Oats Smoothie

Blueberry, strawberry, oats, almond milk

Green Glow Smoothie

Spinach, pineapple, banana, ginger, coconut water

Freshly Squeezed Orange Juice

Grapefruit Juice

Green Juice

Coffee Drip

Iced Coffee

Americano

Espresso

Cappuccino

Latte

Iced or Hot

Cold Brew Coffee

Macchiato

Sides

Breakfast Potato

Onions, pepper, smoked paprika

Croissants

Classic | Add Chocolate for an additional price

Bacon

Sausage

Toast

White Bread | Multigrain | Marble Rye

9 am - 3 pm

Bakery

Croissants

$5.00/Classic
$6.00/Chocolate
G | D | E

Parker House Tostadas

$8.00
shallot butter | G | D | E

Blueberry Muffin

$6.00
G | D | S

Cinnamon Roll

$5.00
cinnamon, cream cheese | G | D

Breakfast

Eggs & Morning Classics

OCI Breakfast

$18.00
Three (3) eggs your way, Bacon or Sausage, home fries & choice of toast | Add two (2) pancakes +$6 | Make a veggie medley omelette +$6

Avocado Toast

$12.00
Smashed avocado, pickled onions, chili flakes, marble rye | Add Poached Egg or Smoked Salmon for an additional price

Shrimp & Grits

$18.00
key west shrimp, creamy stone ground grits, scallion

Buttermilk Pancakes

$12.00
whipped butter, maple syrup, powdered sugar | add ghirardelli milk chocolate chips +$4 | add blueberries +$3

French Toast

$14.00
Cream cheese, guava syrup, caramelized pecans

Breakfast Sandwich

$16.00
Sunny egg, cheddar, Bacon or Sausage Patty, hash brown, spicy mayo, sesame challah bun

Wood Oven Shakshuka

$21.00
Spiced tomato stew, baked eggs, feta, grilled sourdough

Steak & Eggs

$28.00
Marinated steak tips, two eggs any style, breakfast potato & salsa verde

Bagel & Lox

$22.00
smoked salmon, cream cheese, red onion, capers, lemon, dill choice of: plain or anything bagel

Classic Eggs Benedict

$16.00
sunny egg, cheddar, bacon or sausage, spicy mayo, brioche bun

Oci Favorites

Fried Chicken Sliders

$16.00
Coleslaw, b+b pickles, hot honey

Chicken Wings

$14.00/6 pc
$24.00/12 pc
guava BBQ sauce, blue cheese dressing

OCI Double Smashie

Cheddar, onions, b+b pickle, special sauce, sesame challah bun + thick | Add Bacon or Fried Egg for an additional price

Turkey BLT

$15.00
Bacon, little gem, tomato, roasted garlic mayo, Pullman bread

Local Fish Dip

$14.00
pickled fresno, saltine crackers, lemon, OCI hot sauce

Spicy Rigatoni

$28.00
vodka cream sauce, torn basil, chili-garlic breadcrumbs

Baby Back Ribs

$38.00
tamarind bbq, cajun fries, jalapeño cornbread, cole slaw

Local Fried Fish Basket

potato wedges, cole slaw, tartar sauce

Sunday Shuckers

$24.00/Dozen East Coast
$40.00/Dozen Lucky Charms
oysters on the half shell

Breakfast Sides

Breakfast Potato

$7.00
Onions, pepper, smoked paprika

Breakfast Sausage

$7.00

Toast

$4.00
Multigrain | Brioche | Rye

Loaded Wedges

$12.00

Egg Your Way

$4.00

Creamy Grits

$7.00

House Salad

$7.00

Morning Beverage

Oat, Almond, or Whole Milk available

Tropical Sunrise Smoothie

Mango, banana, coconut water

Berry & Oats Smoothie

Blueberry, strawberry, oats, almond milk

Green Glow Smoothie

Spinach, pineapple, banana, ginger, coconut water

Freshly Squeezed OJ

Grapefruit Juice

Green Juice

Coffee Drip

Iced Coffee

Americano

Espresso

Cappuccino

Latte

Iced or Hot

Cold Brew Coffee

Macchiato

  • Book a Party, opens in a new tab