Skip to main content
Old Cutler Inn logo top - HomepageOld Cutler Inn logo scroll - Homepage
  • (305)-432-3556
  • info@oldcutlerinn.com
  • Menus
    • Food
    • Drinks
  • About
  • Private Events
  • Make A Reservation
  • *
  • Press
  • Facebook page
  • Instagram page
Old Cutler Inn logo top - HomepageOld Cutler Inn logo scroll - Homepage
  • Facebook page
  • Instagram page
  • Menus
    • Food
    • Drinks
  • About
  • Private Events
  • Make A Reservation
  • *
  • Press

Our Menu

  • Menu

Raw Bar

East Coast Oyster

Mignonette, cocktail sauce & lemon

Salmon Crudo

Florida citrus kosho, ponzu, green onion, ikura

Key West Shrimp Cocktail

Cocktail sauce, lemon

Corvina Ceviche

Passionfruit leche de tigre, sweet potato, corn nuts

Yellowfin Tuna Tartar

Eggplant caponata, avocado-yuzu, mojo rojo, toston

Appetizers

Warm Parker House Rolls

Caramelized shallot butter

Local Fish Dip

Pickled fresno pepper, aji hot sauce, saltine cracker

Cornmeal-Crusted Calamari

Fried herb, Calabrian chili aioli, grilled lemon

Sebastian Inlet Clams

Tomato broth, chorizo, gremolata, grilled sourdough

Crispy Smoked Chicken Wings

Blue cheese dressing. Choice of: regular grill, buffalo, guava BBQ, or garlic butter

Sourdough Flatbread

Pep & Honey

Pepperoni, mozzarella, marinara, hot honey

Shorty

Smoked short-rib ragù, vodka cream sauce, oven dried tomato, fontina, basil pesto

Fun Guy

Wild mushrooms, prosciutto cotto, fig jam, baby arugula, goat cheese, balsamic reduction

Soup & Salad

French Onion Soup

Onion broth, provolone, sourdough crostini

Wood-Roasted Chicken Caesar

Kale, little gem, boquerones, creamy Caesar dressing, garlic breadcrumb, parmesan

Blackened Shrimp Cobb

Key west shrimp, tomato, bacon, egg, avocado, scallion, blue cheese, apple-cider dressing

Sesame Crusted Yellowfin Tuna

Chopped napa cabbage kimchi, lettuce, edamame, avocado, cucumber, carrot, peanuts, mint, sesame-lime vinaigrette

Steak & Farro Salad

Flatiron, arugula, lardon, roasted pepper, shiitake mushroom, tomato, farro, lemon vinaigrette

Entrées

OCI Double Smashie

Double patty, cheddar, caramelized onion, b+b pickles, special sauce, sesame bun. Thick cut bacon | fried egg

Prime Rib French Dip

Roasted garlic & horseradish cream, caramelized onions, au jus, sesame sourdough

Spicy Vodka Lumanche

Vodka sauce, garlic-lemon breadcrumbs, Calabrian chili

Lasagna

Lamb sugo, truffle fonduta, pecorino romano

Swordfish Steak

Dandelion greens, roasted roots, carrot butterscotch, preserved lemon-caper sauce

½ Oak Roasted Chicken

Fermented aji verde, seasonal greens, seasoned potato wedges

Pork Chop Schnitzel

Warm potato salad, cornichon relish, grainy mustard jus

Korean BBQ Short Rib

Gochujang glaze, napa cabbage kimchi slaw, pickles, scallion rice

Flatiron Steak Frites

Tallow parmesan fries, shallot marmalade & au poivre sauce

8oz Filet Mignon

Potato purée, mushroom ragù, brown butter béarnaise

Sides

Tallow Fried Potato Wedge

special sauce

Ember Roasted Sweet Potato

loaded

Broccolini

chili-garlic crunch

Sautéed Mushroom

  • Reserve
  • Parties
  • Jobs